Published
Jul 30, 2024
Updated
Oct 5, 2024

Can AI Invent Challenging Math Problems? This New Research Says Yes

AI-Assisted Generation of Difficult Math Questions
By
Vedant Shah|Dingli Yu|Kaifeng Lyu|Simon Park|Jiatong Yu|Yinghui He|Nan Rosemary Ke|Michael Mozer|Yoshua Bengio|Sanjeev Arora|Anirudh Goyal

Summary

Imagine an AI that not only solves complex math problems but also *invents* new ones that stump even the smartest large language models (LLMs). That's the intriguing idea explored in "AI-Assisted Generation of Difficult Math Questions." Researchers have designed an innovative framework that combines the strengths of LLMs and human ingenuity to create a dataset of exceptionally challenging math problems, dubbed MATH². Why is this important? Because current methods of evaluating LLMs on math are hitting a wall. Existing datasets are getting stale—LLMs have essentially memorized them—and relying on human experts to craft new, difficult problems isn't scalable. This new research addresses the problem head-on. The process starts by using LLMs to extract core "skills" from existing math problems. These skills, like "ratio and proportion" or "geometric series," become the building blocks for novel questions. The trick? The system pairs up seemingly unrelated skills—say, combining area calculations with prime number knowledge—forcing the LLM to think "outside the box." This clever technique results in problems that are not only difficult but also diverse and engaging for human learners too. The AI doesn't work in isolation. Human experts play a key role in refining the AI-generated questions, making them even more intricate and insightful. This collaboration results in high-quality questions that often stump the very LLMs that helped create them. Interestingly, the research uncovered a curious pattern: an LLM's success rate on MATH² is roughly the square of its success rate on the original MATH dataset. This suggests that MATH² problems genuinely require the mastery of *two* distinct mathematical skills, making them a more robust test of AI reasoning. While the initial results are promising, the current process relies heavily on powerful (and expensive) LLMs like GPT-4. Future work aims to make the process more efficient by incorporating open-source models and automated validation techniques. The ultimate goal is a system that can automatically generate diverse and challenging math problems across a wide range of difficulty levels, keeping LLMs—and their human evaluators—on their toes. This could also have broader implications for education, providing a new way to design challenging and engaging math curricula for students at all levels. Imagine an AI tutor that customizes problems based on your individual strengths and weaknesses – the possibilities are exciting.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does the MATH² framework combine different mathematical skills to generate challenging problems?
The MATH² framework uses LLMs to extract core mathematical skills from existing problems and strategically pairs them together. For example, it might combine 'area calculations' with 'prime number knowledge' to create novel, challenging questions. The process works in three main steps: 1) Skill extraction from existing problems, 2) Strategic pairing of seemingly unrelated skills, and 3) Human expert refinement of the generated questions. This creates problems that require mastery of two distinct mathematical skills, as evidenced by the finding that an LLM's success rate on MATH² is roughly the square of its success rate on the original MATH dataset. In practice, this could mean creating a problem that requires students to calculate the area of a shape while incorporating prime number properties into the solution.
How can AI-generated math problems benefit education and learning?
AI-generated math problems can revolutionize educational approaches by creating personalized, engaging learning experiences. The technology can automatically generate diverse problems across different difficulty levels, allowing for customized learning paths based on individual student needs. Key benefits include: 1) Adaptive difficulty levels that grow with student progress, 2) Unlimited practice problems that prevent memorization, and 3) Creative combinations of concepts that enhance critical thinking. For example, a student struggling with geometry could receive problems that gradually incorporate more complex concepts while maintaining connection to familiar topics they've already mastered.
What are the practical applications of AI in creating educational content?
AI's role in creating educational content offers numerous practical benefits for teachers, students, and educational institutions. It can automate the time-consuming process of developing diverse practice materials, ensure consistent quality across different topics, and adapt to individual learning speeds. The technology can generate unlimited unique problems, preventing students from memorizing answers and encouraging genuine understanding. Real-world applications include personalized homework assignments, interactive online learning platforms, and automated tutoring systems that adjust to student performance. This technology could particularly benefit remote learning environments where personalized attention is challenging to provide.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. The paper's approach to evaluating LLM performance on increasingly complex math problems aligns with systematic testing needs
Implementation Details
Set up batch testing pipelines to evaluate LLM performance across different mathematical skill combinations, track success rates, and validate problem difficulty
Key Benefits
• Systematic evaluation of LLM capabilities across skill domains • Quantifiable measurement of problem difficulty • Automated validation of generated problems
Potential Improvements
• Integration with open-source models for cost efficiency • Automated difficulty scoring system • Real-time performance monitoring
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual testing effort by 70% through automated evaluation
Cost Savings
Optimizes expensive LLM usage by identifying minimum required model capabilities
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent problem difficulty and validity across generations
  1. Workflow Management
  2. The multi-step process of generating, validating, and refining math problems matches workflow orchestration needs
Implementation Details
Create reusable templates for problem generation, implement version tracking for refinements, and establish human-in-the-loop validation workflows
Key Benefits
• Standardized problem generation process • Trackable refinement history • Reproducible results
Potential Improvements
• Enhanced collaboration tools for expert reviewers • Automated skill combination suggestions • Integration with educational content systems
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Streamlines problem generation process by 50% through templated workflows
Cost Savings
Reduces expert review time by implementing structured validation processes
Quality Improvement
Maintains consistent problem quality through standardized workflows

The first platform built for prompt engineering