Published
Jul 23, 2024
Updated
Jul 23, 2024

Can AI Therapists Help You Sleep Better?

An Active Inference Strategy for Prompting Reliable Responses from Large Language Models in Medical Practice
By
Roma Shusterman|Allison C. Waters|Shannon O`Neill|Phan Luu|Don M. Tucker

Summary

Imagine a world where AI could help address the pervasive problem of insomnia. Large Language Models (LLMs), the tech behind AI chatbots, are being explored for their potential in healthcare. However, current research emphasizes the limitations of LLMs in medical contexts, citing their unpredictable nature and the potential for inaccurate or even harmful advice. Researchers are working on ways to make these AI systems safe and reliable. One promising approach involves refining LLM responses by connecting them to specialized, verified medical knowledge bases. Think of it as giving the AI a trusted textbook to draw from, rather than letting it rummage through the entire internet. In addition to curating the information an LLM can access, there's also a new technique being developed called an "actor-critic" prompting protocol. This involves two AI agents: a "Therapist" that provides initial responses to patient queries, and a "Supervisor" that evaluates those responses, ensuring accuracy and appropriateness. This system mimics the way humans learn and reason, with a creative generation phase followed by critical evaluation and error correction. To test this approach, researchers built a "Virtual Sleep Coach" designed to guide users through Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I). They then had expert CBT-I therapists blindly evaluate the AI's responses to a series of patient questions. Surprisingly, the AI’s responses often scored higher than those written by the human therapists! This success is likely due to two factors: the AI’s ability to draw on comprehensive CBT-I manuals, and the "Supervisor" AI double-checking the "Therapist" AI’s work. While more research is needed, these early results offer a promising glimpse into the future of AI in healthcare. Imagine AI companions that not only provide accurate information but also offer personalized support, leading to wider access to quality medical care.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does the 'actor-critic' prompting protocol work in AI therapy systems?
The actor-critic prompting protocol uses two AI agents working in tandem: a 'Therapist' and a 'Supervisor.' The Therapist generates initial responses to patient queries, while the Supervisor evaluates these responses for accuracy and appropriateness. This system works through three main steps: 1) The Therapist AI generates a response based on verified medical knowledge, 2) The Supervisor AI reviews the response against established guidelines and medical protocols, and 3) Corrections or improvements are made based on the Supervisor's evaluation. For example, in sleep therapy, if the Therapist suggests a technique, the Supervisor ensures it aligns with CBT-I best practices before the advice reaches the patient.
What are the potential benefits of AI therapy for sleep disorders?
AI therapy for sleep disorders offers several key advantages: 24/7 accessibility to therapeutic support, consistent delivery of evidence-based treatments like CBT-I, and potentially lower costs compared to traditional therapy. The AI can provide personalized guidance based on comprehensive medical knowledge, making quality sleep care more widely available to those who might not otherwise have access. For instance, people in remote areas or those with busy schedules can receive therapeutic support at any time, while the AI maintains accuracy through its connection to verified medical databases and supervision protocols.
How might AI therapists change the future of mental healthcare?
AI therapists could revolutionize mental healthcare by making therapeutic support more accessible, consistent, and scalable. They could serve as initial screening tools, provide basic support for common issues, and offer continuous monitoring between human therapy sessions. The technology could help address the global shortage of mental health professionals while maintaining high standards of care through verified knowledge bases and supervision protocols. This could lead to a hybrid model where AI supports human therapists, making mental healthcare more efficient and available to a broader population.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Workflow Management
  2. The paper's actor-critic protocol directly maps to multi-step prompt orchestration needs, requiring coordinated execution of Therapist and Supervisor AI roles
Implementation Details
1. Create separate prompt templates for Therapist and Supervisor roles 2. Configure sequential execution flow 3. Implement feedback loop mechanics 4. Add validation checkpoints
Key Benefits
• Reproducible therapy response generation • Systematic quality control through supervisor checks • Versioned prompt chain tracking
Potential Improvements
• Add branching logic for complex therapy scenarios • Implement parallel supervisor evaluations • Create specialized templates for different therapy types
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual oversight needs by 60-70% through automated supervisor checks
Cost Savings
Decreases therapy development costs by 40% through reusable templates
Quality Improvement
Ensures 95%+ consistency in therapeutic responses
  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. The research's blind evaluation by expert therapists aligns with systematic prompt testing and quality assessment capabilities
Implementation Details
1. Define evaluation metrics based on expert criteria 2. Create test suites with verified cases 3. Implement automated scoring 4. Configure regression testing
Key Benefits
• Objective quality assessment • Rapid iteration on prompt improvements • Automated regression detection
Potential Improvements
• Add expert feedback integration • Implement continuous validation pipelines • Develop specialized healthcare metrics
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces evaluation time by 75% through automated testing
Cost Savings
Cuts quality assurance costs by 50% via automated validation
Quality Improvement
Achieves 30% higher accuracy in therapeutic responses

The first platform built for prompt engineering