Published
Oct 25, 2024
Updated
Oct 25, 2024

Can AI Ask Better Clarifying Questions?

AGENT-CQ: Automatic Generation and Evaluation of Clarifying Questions for Conversational Search with LLMs
By
Clemencia Siro|Yifei Yuan|Mohammad Aliannejadi|Maarten de Rijke

Summary

Ever get frustrated with search engines not understanding what you really want? Researchers are exploring how Large Language Models (LLMs) can ask *clarifying questions* to improve search results. Imagine an AI that asks, "Are you looking for information on Java the programming language, the island, or the coffee?" when you search for "Java." This research introduces AGENT-CQ, a framework that uses LLMs to automatically generate and evaluate these clarifying questions in conversational search. It's a two-step process: first, the LLM generates potential clarifying questions based on your initial query, using techniques like exploring different facets of the topic or varying the "temperature" of the model to generate more diverse questions. Then, another LLM acts as a crowd-sourced evaluator, judging the quality of the generated questions based on metrics like clarity, relevance, and usefulness. Surprisingly, the research found that LLM-generated questions often outperform human-written ones in terms of helpfulness and leading to better search results. One method, called GPT-Temp, was particularly effective, suggesting that tweaking the model's temperature is key to unlocking its ability to ask insightful clarifying questions. While there are still challenges, like replicating the natural flow of human conversation and avoiding overly complex questions, this research shows the potential for LLMs to significantly improve how we search for information by understanding what we *really* mean.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does the AGENT-CQ framework technically implement its two-step process for generating and evaluating clarifying questions?
The AGENT-CQ framework operates through a dual-LLM approach. First, it uses an LLM to generate questions by exploring topic facets and varying temperature settings to produce diverse queries. The generation phase involves manipulating the model's temperature parameter (GPT-Temp method) to control response creativity and diversity. Second, a separate LLM acts as an evaluator, assessing questions based on specific metrics like clarity, relevance, and usefulness. For example, when searching for 'smartphone,' the system might generate questions about brand preferences, intended use cases, and budget constraints, then evaluate these questions' effectiveness in narrowing down search results.
How can AI-powered clarifying questions improve the everyday search experience?
AI-powered clarifying questions make searching more intuitive and accurate by helping users find exactly what they're looking for. Instead of getting irrelevant results, the system asks smart follow-up questions to understand user intent better. For instance, when searching for 'apple,' the AI might ask whether you're interested in the fruit, the technology company, or recipes. This approach saves time, reduces frustration, and delivers more precise results. It's particularly useful in e-commerce, research, and customer service scenarios where specific information needs to be located quickly and accurately.
What are the main benefits of using AI to generate clarifying questions compared to traditional search methods?
AI-generated clarifying questions offer several advantages over traditional search methods. First, they can understand context and nuance better than simple keyword matching. The research shows that LLM-generated questions often perform better than human-written ones in terms of helpfulness. These systems can adapt to user responses in real-time, creating a more interactive and precise search experience. For businesses, this means improved customer satisfaction, reduced support tickets, and more efficient information retrieval. Examples include online shopping platforms that can quickly narrow down product searches or educational platforms that can better understand student queries.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. Aligns with the paper's two-step evaluation process where LLMs assess question quality using metrics like clarity and relevance
Implementation Details
Set up A/B testing pipelines to compare different temperature settings and evaluation criteria for clarifying questions, implement scoring systems for question quality metrics
Key Benefits
• Systematic comparison of question generation approaches • Quantifiable quality metrics for generated questions • Reproducible evaluation framework
Potential Improvements
• Add human feedback integration • Implement automated regression testing • Develop custom scoring algorithms
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual evaluation time by 70% through automated testing
Cost Savings
Minimizes expensive human evaluation needs while maintaining quality
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent question quality across different model configurations
  1. Workflow Management
  2. Supports the paper's multi-step process of question generation and evaluation using different model configurations
Implementation Details
Create reusable templates for question generation and evaluation, implement version tracking for different temperature settings, orchestrate multi-step evaluation process
Key Benefits
• Streamlined question generation pipeline • Versioned control of model parameters • Reproducible workflow execution
Potential Improvements
• Add dynamic temperature adjustment • Implement parallel processing • Create adaptive workflow patterns
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces workflow setup time by 60% through templated processes
Cost Savings
Optimizes resource usage through structured workflows
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent process execution across different scenarios

The first platform built for prompt engineering