Published
Jun 29, 2024
Updated
Nov 18, 2024

Guaranteeing LLM Correctness with Conformal Uncertainty

ConU: Conformal Uncertainty in Large Language Models with Correctness Coverage Guarantees
By
Zhiyuan Wang|Jinhao Duan|Lu Cheng|Yue Zhang|Qingni Wang|Xiaoshuang Shi|Kaidi Xu|Hengtao Shen|Xiaofeng Zhu

Summary

Large language models (LLMs) are impressive, but they can sometimes generate incorrect or nonsensical information, a problem known as 'hallucination.' Ensuring LLMs produce reliable, accurate content is a critical challenge, especially in fields like medicine where errors can have serious consequences. Researchers are exploring new ways to quantify and control these uncertainties, and a recent paper introduces a promising technique called 'Conformal Uncertainty' (ConU). ConU works by cleverly measuring the uncertainty within an LLM's output space, rather than relying on potentially misleading confidence scores. It leverages the idea that if an LLM generates many diverse outputs for the same question, it's likely less certain about the correct answer. ConU clusters similar answers together and calculates the uncertainty based on how diverse these clusters are. This 'uncertainty score' is then used to create a set of possible answers that are most likely to contain the correct one. This approach offers statistical guarantees about the accuracy of the generated answer sets, even without needing to understand the complex inner workings of the LLM. Tests show that ConU consistently outperforms other uncertainty methods and accurately predicts the correctness of LLM responses. More importantly, these sets of probable answers tend to be small, making it easier to identify the most likely correct answer. ConU also has the potential to improve the overall accuracy of LLMs by allowing them to abstain from answering questions with high uncertainty, or to present a range of possible responses when complete certainty isn't possible. While promising, ConU has limitations. One challenge is knowing if a correct answer was even sampled among the generated outputs, particularly in real-world applications. Future work will explore extending ConU to other NLG tasks like summarization and refining its application for non-standard situations. Overall, ConU represents a significant step toward making LLMs more trustworthy and reliable for critical applications.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does Conformal Uncertainty (ConU) technically measure uncertainty in LLM outputs?
ConU measures uncertainty by analyzing the diversity of multiple outputs generated for the same input query. Technically, it works through three main steps: 1) Generate multiple responses from the LLM for the same question, 2) Cluster similar answers together to identify distinct response patterns, 3) Calculate an uncertainty score based on the diversity and distribution of these clusters. For example, if an LLM is asked 'What's the capital of France?' and generates 'Paris' consistently across multiple attempts with minimal variations, ConU would indicate low uncertainty. However, if responses vary significantly or form multiple distinct clusters, it would indicate higher uncertainty.
What are the main benefits of uncertainty detection in AI systems?
Uncertainty detection in AI systems helps ensure more reliable and trustworthy results by identifying when the system might be unsure or potentially incorrect. The main benefits include: 1) Improved decision safety by flagging potentially unreliable outputs, 2) Enhanced user trust through transparency about system limitations, and 3) Better risk management in critical applications. For instance, in healthcare, uncertainty detection could help doctors know when to seek additional verification of AI-generated diagnoses, or in financial services, it could flag high-risk automated trading decisions for human review.
How can AI uncertainty measurement improve everyday decision-making?
AI uncertainty measurement helps make better decisions by providing clarity about when to trust AI recommendations and when to seek additional information. This applies to everyday situations like using AI-powered GPS navigation (knowing when route suggestions might be unreliable), virtual assistants (understanding when responses might need verification), or online shopping recommendations (recognizing when suggestions might not be fully relevant). By understanding AI uncertainty, users can make more informed choices about when to rely on AI guidance and when to incorporate other sources of information or human judgment.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. ConU's uncertainty measurement approach can be integrated into PromptLayer's testing framework to evaluate response reliability
Implementation Details
1. Generate multiple responses per prompt, 2. Apply ConU clustering to measure uncertainty, 3. Set confidence thresholds for automated testing
Key Benefits
• Automated reliability scoring of responses • Statistical confidence measures for testing • Early detection of potential hallucinations
Potential Improvements
• Add native clustering analysis tools • Implement uncertainty threshold configurations • Create visualization tools for response clusters
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual validation effort by automatically identifying uncertain responses
Cost Savings
Prevents costly errors by flagging unreliable outputs before deployment
Quality Improvement
Enables systematic improvement of prompt reliability through quantitative metrics
  1. Analytics Integration
  2. ConU's uncertainty metrics can enhance PromptLayer's analytics capabilities for monitoring LLM response quality
Implementation Details
1. Track uncertainty scores across requests, 2. Monitor clustering patterns over time, 3. Generate uncertainty-based performance reports
Key Benefits
• Real-time uncertainty monitoring • Pattern detection in unreliable responses • Data-driven prompt optimization
Potential Improvements
• Add uncertainty trend analysis • Implement automated alerting for high uncertainty • Create uncertainty-based cost optimization suggestions
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Enables proactive identification of problematic prompt patterns
Cost Savings
Optimizes token usage by identifying high-uncertainty scenarios
Quality Improvement
Provides quantitative metrics for continuous prompt enhancement

The first platform built for prompt engineering