Published
Aug 5, 2024
Updated
Aug 5, 2024

From LLMs to Agents: Revolutionizing Software Engineering?

From LLMs to LLM-based Agents for Software Engineering: A Survey of Current, Challenges and Future
By
Haolin Jin|Linghan Huang|Haipeng Cai|Jun Yan|Bo Li|Huaming Chen

Summary

The world of software engineering is undergoing a seismic shift, thanks to the rise of large language models (LLMs). Initially, LLMs like GPT and Codex impressed with their code generation and bug detection abilities. But they weren't without limitations—context length restrictions, occasional "hallucinations" (generating incorrect code), and an inability to use external tools hampered their full potential. Now, the evolution continues with LLM-based agents stepping into the spotlight. These agents combine the language prowess of LLMs with the dynamic power of external tools and resources. Think of an LLM as a brilliant coder, and the agent as its resourceful manager, providing the right tools and information at the right time. This shift enables agents to tackle more complex, context-aware tasks. Instead of simply generating code snippets, they can autonomously debug, refactor, and even generate adaptive test cases that evolve with the codebase. This survey paper explores the exciting transition from LLMs to agents across six key software engineering areas: requirement engineering, code generation, autonomous decision-making, software design, test generation, and software maintenance. The research digs into the differences between LLMs and agents, comparing their tasks, benchmarks, and evaluation metrics across these domains. One key takeaway is the increasing autonomy of LLM-based agents. While LLMs excel at specific tasks, agents can orchestrate entire workflows, dynamically choosing the right tools and strategies. Imagine an agent autonomously managing a software project, assigning tasks, and ensuring code quality – this is the future LLM-based agents are building. The survey also highlights the challenges of evaluating these sophisticated systems. Traditional metrics like precision and recall are still relevant, but new measures are needed to capture the agents' dynamic and collaborative nature. How do you measure an agent's ability to adapt and learn? This is a key question researchers are grappling with. The shift from LLMs to agents marks a significant leap towards automating and optimizing the software development lifecycle. While challenges remain, the potential of these intelligent agents to revolutionize software engineering is undeniable. As researchers continue to refine these agents, expect to see even more sophisticated and autonomous systems shaping the future of software creation.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How do LLM-based agents differ from traditional LLMs in software engineering tasks?
LLM-based agents represent an evolution beyond traditional LLMs by combining language capabilities with external tool integration. Technically, while LLMs operate as isolated models processing text/code, agents function as orchestrators that can: 1) Access and utilize external tools and resources, 2) Maintain context across multiple interactions, and 3) Autonomously make decisions about workflow steps. For example, in a debugging scenario, while an LLM might only suggest code fixes, an agent could automatically run tests, access documentation, implement fixes, and verify the solutions - creating a complete debugging workflow without human intervention.
What are the main benefits of AI agents in software development for businesses?
AI agents in software development offer several key advantages for businesses. They streamline development workflows by automating routine tasks like code generation, testing, and maintenance, potentially reducing development time and costs. These agents can work 24/7, maintaining consistent code quality and following best practices without fatigue. For example, they can automatically generate test cases, identify bugs, and suggest optimizations, allowing human developers to focus on more creative and strategic aspects of software development. This can lead to faster project completion, reduced errors, and more efficient resource allocation.
How is artificial intelligence changing the way we create software?
Artificial intelligence is revolutionizing software creation through automated processes and intelligent assistance. It's transforming traditional coding practices by offering real-time code suggestions, automated testing, and even autonomous project management. For businesses and developers, this means faster development cycles, reduced errors, and more efficient resource utilization. The technology can handle everything from initial requirement analysis to ongoing maintenance, allowing human developers to focus on innovation and complex problem-solving. This shift is making software development more accessible while improving code quality and consistency.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Workflow Management
  2. The paper highlights LLM-based agents orchestrating complex software development workflows, which directly relates to PromptLayer's workflow management capabilities
Implementation Details
Create multi-step templates for common software engineering tasks, integrate external tools via API connections, implement version tracking for workflow iterations
Key Benefits
• Automated orchestration of complex development tasks • Reproducible software engineering workflows • Seamless integration with external development tools
Potential Improvements
• Add dynamic workflow adaptation based on feedback • Implement parallel workflow execution capabilities • Enhance workflow visualization tools
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual coordination overhead by 40-60% through automated workflow orchestration
Cost Savings
Decreases development costs by 30% through optimized resource allocation and automated task management
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent quality through standardized workflows and automated quality checks
  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. The paper discusses challenges in evaluating LLM-based agents, aligning with PromptLayer's testing and evaluation infrastructure
Implementation Details
Set up automated testing pipelines, implement comparative testing frameworks, establish evaluation metrics tracking
Key Benefits
• Comprehensive evaluation of agent performance • Automated regression testing • Data-driven improvement cycles
Potential Improvements
• Develop new metrics for agent evaluation • Implement real-time performance monitoring • Add collaborative testing features
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces testing time by 50% through automated evaluation pipelines
Cost Savings
Minimizes debugging costs by catching issues early through comprehensive testing
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent agent performance through systematic evaluation and monitoring

The first platform built for prompt engineering