Published
Jul 17, 2024
Updated
Nov 9, 2024

Can AI Learn to Plan? Bridging the Gap Between Language and Action

Leveraging Environment Interaction for Automated PDDL Translation and Planning with Large Language Models
By
Sadegh Mahdavi|Raquel Aoki|Keyi Tang|Yanshuai Cao

Summary

Imagine asking an AI to not just write a story, but to actually perform tasks in a virtual world. Sounds simple enough, right? It turns out that getting AI to plan and execute actions, even in a simulated environment, is surprisingly difficult. While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at understanding and generating text, they struggle with the structured reasoning required for planning. This is where the Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL) comes in. PDDL provides a formal way to describe planning problems, allowing AI systems to use classical planning algorithms to find solutions. Think of it as a precise set of instructions that a computer can follow to achieve a goal. The challenge, however, lies in translating natural language instructions into this formal PDDL format. Traditionally, this requires human expertise, which is both time-consuming and expensive. New research proposes a solution: letting the AI learn PDDL directly by interacting with its environment. This innovative approach involves an iterative process where the LLM proposes PDDL descriptions, tests them in the environment, and refines them based on the feedback received. It's like a child learning by trial and error, but with the precision of a computer program. A key innovation is the introduction of the "Exploration Walk" (EW) metric. EW measures how well the LLM's PDDL description aligns with the actual environment. This feedback helps the LLM refine its PDDL, improving its planning accuracy over time. Experiments on 10 different planning domains show that this method significantly outperforms LLMs that attempt to plan without interacting with the environment. The results demonstrate the potential of this approach to create more reliable and autonomous AI agents. While promising, the research also highlights the challenges of predicate design in PDDL. Getting the precise definitions of objects and their relationships is crucial for accurate planning. Future research could explore more sophisticated exploration strategies and apply this framework to more complex digital and even physical environments. This work opens up exciting possibilities for the future of AI, paving the way for agents that can not only understand our commands but also effectively plan and execute actions in the real world.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does the Exploration Walk (EW) metric work in improving AI planning capabilities?
The Exploration Walk metric is a feedback mechanism that measures how well an AI's PDDL (Planning Domain Definition Language) description matches the actual environment. Technically, it works through an iterative process where: 1) The LLM generates a PDDL description, 2) The system tests this description in the environment, 3) The EW metric evaluates the alignment between predicted and actual outcomes, and 4) The LLM refines its PDDL based on this feedback. For example, in a virtual kitchen environment, EW would measure if the AI's understanding of actions like 'grab_cup' or 'pour_water' accurately reflects what's possible in the environment, helping it improve its action planning over time.
What are the main benefits of AI planning systems in everyday applications?
AI planning systems offer significant advantages in automating complex decision-making processes in daily life. These systems can help organize tasks, optimize schedules, and create efficient workflows in various scenarios. The main benefits include reduced human error, faster decision-making, and more efficient resource allocation. For example, AI planners can help in smart home automation, travel itinerary planning, or managing business operations. In practical terms, they can automatically adjust your home's temperature based on your schedule, suggest the most efficient route for running errands, or help businesses optimize their supply chain operations.
How is artificial intelligence changing the way we interact with virtual environments?
AI is revolutionizing virtual environment interactions by making them more intuitive and responsive to human input. Instead of rigid, pre-programmed responses, AI enables dynamic, context-aware interactions that can understand and adapt to user needs. This advancement is particularly valuable in gaming, virtual training simulations, and digital assistants. For instance, AI can create more realistic virtual characters that respond naturally to player actions, power virtual training environments that adapt to learner progress, or enable more sophisticated virtual assistants that can understand and execute complex commands. This makes virtual experiences more engaging, effective, and user-friendly.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. The paper's Exploration Walk (EW) metric for evaluating PDDL accuracy aligns with PromptLayer's testing capabilities
Implementation Details
Set up automated testing pipelines that track prompt performance across multiple planning domains, implement EW metric as a custom evaluation metric, and create regression tests for PDDL generation
Key Benefits
• Systematic evaluation of prompt effectiveness in planning tasks • Automated tracking of performance improvements over iterations • Standardized testing across different planning domains
Potential Improvements
• Integration with custom metrics like EW • Enhanced visualization of performance trends • Support for domain-specific testing scenarios
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual testing effort by 70% through automation
Cost Savings
Cuts evaluation time and resource usage by identifying optimal prompts faster
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent planning performance across different domains
  1. Workflow Management
  2. The iterative refinement process of PDDL learning maps to PromptLayer's workflow orchestration capabilities
Implementation Details
Create multi-step workflows for PDDL generation, testing, and refinement, with version tracking for each iteration
Key Benefits
• Structured management of iterative learning process • Version control for PDDL descriptions • Reproducible refinement workflows
Potential Improvements
• Enhanced feedback loop automation • Better integration with environment simulators • More sophisticated version comparison tools
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Streamlines the PDDL refinement process with automated workflows
Cost Savings
Reduces development time through reusable templates and automated processes
Quality Improvement
Better tracking and control of the learning process leads to more reliable results

The first platform built for prompt engineering