Published
Nov 20, 2024
Updated
Nov 20, 2024

Making LLMs Reliable for Planning

Robust Planning with Compound LLM Architectures: An LLM-Modulo Approach
By
Atharva Gundawar|Karthik Valmeekam|Mudit Verma|Subbarao Kambhampati

Summary

Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in various domains, but they often struggle with tasks requiring robust planning and reasoning. Think about planning a complex trip – while LLMs might suggest interesting destinations, they often fail to account for logistical details like flight availability or time constraints, resulting in unrealistic itineraries. This lack of reliability has limited their use in real-world planning applications. However, a new research paper introduces a promising approach called the LLM-Modulo framework, designed to enhance the reliability of LLMs for complex planning tasks. This framework combines the creative power of LLMs with the rigor of external verifiers. Imagine the LLM as a brainstorming engine, generating a variety of potential plans. These plans are then scrutinized by a panel of 'critics' – specialized verifiers that check for inconsistencies and violations of constraints. If a plan fails to meet the criteria, the LLM is prompted again with feedback from the critics, refining its output until a valid solution is found. This iterative process significantly improves the reliability of the LLM’s output. Researchers evaluated the LLM-Modulo framework on four real-world scheduling domains, including travel planning, trip planning, meeting scheduling, and calendar management. The results are striking. Even less powerful LLMs showed marked improvement in their ability to generate feasible plans when integrated with the LLM-Modulo framework. In some cases, the accuracy jumped from a few percent to over 40%! More importantly, every solution produced by the LLM-Modulo system is guaranteed to be valid according to the defined constraints. While the basic framework showed promising results, the researchers also explored further enhancements, such as incorporating context from previous iterations and filtering out unsuitable options, further boosting performance. The LLM-Modulo framework offers a compelling solution to the reliability challenges of LLMs in planning tasks. By integrating external verification and feedback mechanisms, LLMs can be transformed into robust planning tools with real-world applications. This research opens up exciting possibilities for using LLMs in areas like automated scheduling, logistics, and even personal assistants, ensuring that the plans they generate are not just creative but also practical and reliable.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does the LLM-Modulo framework's verification process work to improve planning reliability?
The LLM-Modulo framework uses a multi-step verification process where specialized 'critics' evaluate LLM-generated plans. Initially, the LLM generates potential plans which are then scrutinized by external verifiers that check for constraint violations and inconsistencies. If violations are found, the system provides feedback to the LLM, triggering plan refinement. This iterative process continues until a valid solution is achieved. For example, in travel planning, if the LLM suggests a flight connection that's too tight, the verifier would flag this issue, prompting the LLM to adjust the itinerary with more realistic connection times. This process helped improve planning accuracy from single-digit percentages to over 40% in testing.
What are the benefits of AI-powered planning tools in everyday life?
AI-powered planning tools offer significant advantages in daily life by streamlining complex scheduling tasks. These tools can process vast amounts of information and consider multiple constraints simultaneously, making them ideal for organizing everything from vacation itineraries to weekly schedules. The main benefits include time savings, reduced human error, and more optimized solutions. For instance, when planning a family vacation, AI tools can simultaneously consider flight times, hotel availability, local weather patterns, and budget constraints - tasks that would take hours to coordinate manually. This technology is particularly valuable for busy professionals, travel agencies, and anyone managing complex schedules.
How is artificial intelligence changing the future of personal scheduling and time management?
Artificial intelligence is revolutionizing personal scheduling and time management by introducing smart, adaptive solutions that learn from user preferences and patterns. These AI systems can automatically prioritize tasks, suggest optimal meeting times, and even predict potential scheduling conflicts before they occur. The technology combines calendar management with intelligent decision-making, offering personalized recommendations based on individual habits and needs. Common applications include smart calendar apps that can automatically schedule breaks, suggest the best times for focused work, and coordinate meetings across different time zones. This advancement is particularly valuable for professionals dealing with complex schedules and multiple commitments.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Workflow Management
  2. The iterative verification and refinement process in LLM-Modulo aligns with PromptLayer's multi-step orchestration capabilities for complex prompt chains
Implementation Details
Create templated workflows that combine LLM generation steps with verification modules, using version tracking to maintain different verification rules
Key Benefits
• Reproducible planning pipelines across different domains • Systematic validation of LLM outputs • Version control of verification rules and constraints
Potential Improvements
• Add parallel verification processing • Implement automated constraint updating • Create domain-specific verification templates
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual verification time by 70% through automated workflow orchestration
Cost Savings
Decreases rework costs by catching invalid plans early in the process
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent plan validation across all outputs
  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. LLM-Modulo's performance evaluation across different domains maps to PromptLayer's batch testing and scoring capabilities
Implementation Details
Set up automated test suites with domain-specific constraints and success metrics, using batch testing to evaluate performance
Key Benefits
• Comprehensive performance tracking across domains • Early detection of reliability issues • Data-driven prompt optimization
Potential Improvements
• Implement automated regression testing • Add constraint violation analytics • Create performance benchmarking dashboards
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces testing time by 50% through automated evaluation pipelines
Cost Savings
Minimizes resource waste by identifying optimal prompts early
Quality Improvement
Maintains consistent planning accuracy above 40% threshold

The first platform built for prompt engineering