Published
Oct 22, 2024
Updated
Oct 22, 2024

Protecting Your Privacy from AI

PAPILLON: PrivAcy Preservation from Internet-based and Local Language MOdel ENsembles
By
Li Siyan|Vethavikashini Chithrra Raghuram|Omar Khattab|Julia Hirschberg|Zhou Yu

Summary

Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT are incredibly powerful tools, but what happens when you need to share sensitive information with them? Imagine applying for a job and wanting AI to help draft your application email. You’d need to give it your resume, full of personal details. This poses a significant privacy risk. Researchers are exploring how to balance the utility of these powerful AI models with the crucial need for privacy. A new research project called PAPILLON (PrivAcy Preservation from Internet-based and Local Language MOdel ENsembles) introduces a clever approach: using a “privacy-conscious proxy.” This involves running a smaller, less powerful LLM locally on your device. This local LLM acts as a gatekeeper, interacting with the powerful, external LLM on your behalf. It carefully crafts prompts for the external LLM, scrubbing out sensitive details while still retaining enough information to generate useful responses. Essentially, it learns to ask the external LLM questions in a way that protects your privacy. To test this, researchers created a benchmark dataset called PUPA (Private User Prompt Annotations) using real user interactions with LLMs, focusing on scenarios involving job applications, financial information, and emails. They then tested different combinations of local and external LLMs in a pipeline. The most effective approach used Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct as the local proxy and GPT-4o-mini as the external LLM. This combination successfully generated high-quality responses while minimizing the leakage of private information. While promising, this research is just the beginning. The gap in performance between using the external LLM directly and using the privacy-preserving proxy still exists. Future work will focus on training specialized privacy-conscious models and refining the pipeline to improve performance and ensure your sensitive information stays protected while you benefit from the power of AI.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does PAPILLON's privacy-conscious proxy system work to protect user data?
PAPILLON uses a two-tier LLM system where a smaller, local LLM acts as a privacy gatekeeper. The system works through three main steps: 1) The local LLM runs directly on the user's device and receives the original, sensitive prompt, 2) It processes and sanitizes the input by removing personal information while preserving the essential context, 3) The sanitized prompt is then sent to the more powerful external LLM (like GPT-4) for processing. For example, when helping with a job application, the local LLM might remove specific dates, addresses, and personal identifiers from your resume while maintaining the core professional experience details needed for generating advice.
What are the main privacy risks when sharing personal information with AI chatbots?
AI chatbots can pose several privacy risks when handling personal information. These systems typically store conversations and data inputs, which could potentially be vulnerable to breaches or unauthorized access. Additionally, the data might be used for model training or analysis without explicit consent. Common scenarios include sharing financial details, medical information, or professional documents like resumes. For everyday users, this means sensitive information like addresses, phone numbers, or employment history could be exposed. The best practice is to be cautious about sharing personal identifiers and sensitive information when using AI chatbots.
How can individuals protect their privacy while still benefiting from AI assistance?
Individuals can protect their privacy while using AI by following several key practices: 1) Use privacy-focused AI tools that process data locally when possible, 2) Avoid sharing specific personal identifiers like full names, addresses, or financial details, 3) Sanitize information before sharing by removing sensitive details while keeping the essential context, and 4) Check the privacy policies of AI services being used. For example, when getting help with a document review, you could replace actual names and specific details with placeholders while maintaining the overall structure and content needed for meaningful AI assistance.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Prompt Management
  2. Managing privacy-conscious prompt templates and transformations needed for the local-external LLM interaction pipeline
Implementation Details
Create versioned prompt templates with privacy-focused parameters, implement access controls for sensitive data handling, maintain separate prompt versions for local and external LLMs
Key Benefits
• Centralized management of privacy-preserving prompt patterns • Version control for evolving privacy requirements • Secure collaboration on sensitive prompt development
Potential Improvements
• Automated privacy compliance checking • Enhanced prompt sanitization tools • Privacy-focused prompt suggestion system
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduced time spent manually sanitizing sensitive data
Cost Savings
Lower risk of privacy breaches and associated costs
Quality Improvement
Consistent privacy protection across all AI interactions
  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. Evaluating privacy preservation effectiveness using the PUPA benchmark dataset and measuring response quality
Implementation Details
Set up automated testing pipelines using PUPA dataset, implement privacy metrics, conduct A/B tests between different local-external LLM combinations
Key Benefits
• Systematic privacy preservation validation • Quantifiable privacy-utility trade-off assessment • Continuous monitoring of information leakage
Potential Improvements
• Real-time privacy breach detection • Advanced privacy metric tracking • Automated regression testing for privacy
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Faster validation of privacy-preserving implementations
Cost Savings
Reduced privacy compliance audit costs
Quality Improvement
Better balance between utility and privacy protection

The first platform built for prompt engineering