Published
Jun 22, 2024
Updated
Oct 29, 2024

Taming Wild LLMs: How RuleR Makes AI Follow the Rules

RuleR: Improving LLM Controllability by Rule-based Data Recycling
By
Ming Li|Han Chen|Chenguang Wang|Dang Nguyen|Dianqi Li|Tianyi Zhou

Summary

Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful, but sometimes they're like wild horses—brilliant, but difficult to control. They can write poems, translate languages, and even generate code, but making them follow specific rules, like formatting text or including particular keywords, can be a challenge. This lack of controllability is a major hurdle in making LLMs truly useful in real-world applications. Imagine asking an LLM to write a report and it ignores your formatting guidelines or omits crucial keywords for SEO. Not ideal, right? Researchers have now developed a clever method called RuleR (Rule-based Data Recycling) to address this issue. Instead of creating entirely new training data, which is expensive and time-consuming, RuleR recycles existing data. It works by taking existing instruction-response pairs and adding rule-based constraints. For example, it might add a rule like, "Ensure the response contains the keyword 'technology' three times." Then, it automatically modifies the response to satisfy the new rule. This clever trick allows LLMs to learn how to follow these rules without requiring humans or other AI models to painstakingly create new examples. The results? LLMs trained with RuleR show significant improvements in following constraints while still maintaining their general ability to follow instructions. This breakthrough has big implications for making LLMs more reliable and controllable, opening doors to applications that require precise output, like automated report generation, chatbot interactions, and even code generation. While RuleR represents a significant step forward, the research team acknowledges there's still room for improvement. Currently, RuleR focuses on structural rules like formatting and keyword usage. The next step is to expand its capabilities to include semantic constraints, allowing for even finer control over the meaning and content of the generated text. Imagine being able to specify not just that a keyword must appear, but also the specific sentiment it should convey! The journey to truly taming these wild LLMs has just begun, but RuleR has illuminated the path toward a future where AI follows our rules, not the other way around.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does RuleR's data recycling mechanism work to improve LLM rule-following?
RuleR works by modifying existing instruction-response pairs with rule-based constraints, rather than creating new training data from scratch. The process involves: 1) Taking existing training pairs, 2) Adding specific constraints (e.g., keyword requirements or formatting rules), and 3) Automatically modifying the responses to satisfy these new rules. For example, if working with a customer service dataset, RuleR might add a rule requiring each response to include a polite greeting and specific product terminology, then modify existing responses to meet these criteria. This approach is more efficient than traditional methods that require manual creation of new training examples.
What are the main benefits of making AI models more controllable?
Making AI models more controllable offers several key advantages for businesses and users. First, it ensures consistency and reliability in AI outputs, making them more suitable for professional applications. Second, it allows for customization to specific business needs, such as maintaining brand voice or following industry regulations. Third, it reduces the need for human oversight and corrections. For example, a marketing team could use controllable AI to generate content that consistently includes required disclaimers, follows brand guidelines, and maintains specific messaging without constant manual review.
How can rule-based AI improve content creation workflows?
Rule-based AI can significantly streamline content creation workflows by ensuring automated outputs meet specific requirements consistently. It helps maintain quality standards by automatically following formatting guidelines, including required keywords, and adhering to style guides. For content teams, this means less time spent on revisions and more focus on strategic tasks. For instance, a blog writing team could use rule-based AI to generate drafts that already include optimal keyword density, proper headers, and required citations, significantly reducing editing time and improving SEO compliance.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. RuleR's rule-based approach aligns with systematic prompt testing needs, enabling validation of constraint compliance across different prompt versions
Implementation Details
Create test suites with specific formatting rules and keyword requirements, run batch tests to verify constraint compliance, track success rates across versions
Key Benefits
• Automated validation of rule adherence • Systematic comparison of prompt versions • Quantifiable performance metrics
Potential Improvements
• Add semantic rule validation capabilities • Implement custom scoring for rule compliance • Develop automated regression testing
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual validation time by 70% through automated rule checking
Cost Savings
Minimizes expensive retraining by identifying rule violations early
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent rule compliance across all LLM outputs
  1. Prompt Management
  2. RuleR's constraint modification approach requires systematic versioning and organization of rule-enhanced prompts
Implementation Details
Create template library with rule variations, version control rule modifications, implement collaborative rule development
Key Benefits
• Centralized rule management • Trackable prompt evolution • Collaborative rule refinement
Potential Improvements
• Add rule inheritance system • Implement rule conflict detection • Create rule template marketplace
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces prompt development time by 50% through reusable rule templates
Cost Savings
Decreases duplicate rule creation costs through centralized management
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent rule application across team members

The first platform built for prompt engineering