Published
May 7, 2024
Updated
May 10, 2024

Sketch and Generate: Giving Instant Feedback to LLMs for Better Code

Sketch Then Generate: Providing Incremental User Feedback and Guiding LLM Code Generation through Language-Oriented Code Sketches
By
Chen Zhu-Tian|Zeyu Xiong|Xiaoshuo Yao|Elena Glassman

Summary

Generating code with Large Language Models (LLMs) can be like giving someone vague directions – you're never quite sure what you'll get. A new research project called "Sketch Then Generate" aims to fix this by letting users give LLMs real-time feedback as they write their prompts. Imagine sketching out the structure of your code in plain language, and having the LLM respond instantly with suggestions. This "language-oriented code sketching" uses natural language processing (NLP) to turn your prompt into an incomplete code outline, or sketch. As you type, the system maps your words to code elements, assembling them based on the relationships between the words. For example, "create a Python function to read a file" would be mapped to function definition and file I/O operations. The system then suggests relevant code snippets, and you can choose the ones that fit your intent. This interactive process not only gives you a preview of the code structure but also guides the LLM toward generating the code you actually want. The research team tested this approach with a prototype and found that it reduced the cognitive load on users, making it easier to control the LLM's output. Even when the initial sketch wasn't perfect, users appreciated the ability to see how the LLM interpreted their prompt and correct it along the way. This approach is especially helpful when you have a general idea of what you want your code to do but are unsure of the specific implementation details. While the current system is limited to Python and English, the researchers plan to expand it to other languages and explore how this "sketch-then-generate" concept could be applied to other creative fields like graphic design. This research points towards a future where interacting with LLMs feels less like guesswork and more like a collaborative partnership, bridging the gap between human intention and AI generation.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does the language-oriented code sketching system map natural language to code elements?
The system uses natural language processing (NLP) to convert plain language prompts into code structure elements. The process involves identifying key programming concepts and their relationships within the user's text input. For example, when a user types 'create a Python function to read a file,' the system maps this to specific code elements like function definition syntax and file I/O operations. This mapping happens in real-time as the user types, creating an interactive feedback loop. The system maintains relationships between words and their corresponding code elements, allowing it to suggest relevant code snippets that match the user's intended structure. This provides immediate visual feedback and helps users refine their prompts for more accurate code generation.
What are the benefits of interactive AI code generation for developers?
Interactive AI code generation offers developers a more intuitive and efficient way to create code. Instead of writing complete code from scratch, developers can describe their needs in plain language and get instant feedback. This approach reduces development time, lowers the learning curve for new programmers, and helps catch potential issues early in the development process. For example, a developer working on a new feature can quickly prototype different approaches by sketching out the structure in natural language, seeing the proposed implementation, and adjusting their requirements on the fly. This collaborative approach between human and AI leads to more accurate and maintainable code while reducing the cognitive load on developers.
How is AI changing the way we write and develop software?
AI is revolutionizing software development by making it more accessible and efficient through natural language interactions. Traditional coding requires detailed knowledge of programming syntax and structures, but AI-powered tools are enabling developers to express their ideas in plain language and receive intelligent suggestions. This transformation is particularly beneficial for rapid prototyping, learning programming concepts, and exploring different implementation approaches. The technology is evolving to become more interactive and collaborative, allowing developers to focus on problem-solving and creativity rather than syntax details. This shift is making software development more inclusive and productive while maintaining the quality and reliability of the final code.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Prompt Management
  2. The paper's sketch-then-generate approach aligns with structured prompt versioning and iterative refinement
Implementation Details
Create templated prompts that include code structure sketches, version control different sketch approaches, and track successful patterns
Key Benefits
• Reproducible code generation patterns • Standardized sketch-to-code mappings • Collaborative prompt improvement
Potential Improvements
• Add sketch template library • Implement multi-language support • Create sketch validation tools
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
50% faster prompt iteration through structured templates
Cost Savings
Reduced token usage by pre-validating sketches
Quality Improvement
More consistent and accurate code generation outputs
  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. Real-time feedback system requires robust testing infrastructure to validate sketch-to-code mappings
Implementation Details
Set up automated testing pipelines for sketch validation, code generation quality, and user feedback integration
Key Benefits
• Immediate validation of sketches • Quality metrics for generated code • User feedback incorporation
Potential Improvements
• Add automated code quality checks • Implement success rate tracking • Create feedback collection system
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
75% reduction in iteration cycles
Cost Savings
Decreased debugging time through early validation
Quality Improvement
Higher success rate in first-pass code generation

The first platform built for prompt engineering