Published
May 29, 2024
Updated
May 29, 2024

Can AI Answer Medical Questions from Reddit?

Two-layer retrieval augmented generation framework for low-resource medical question-answering: proof of concept using Reddit data
By
Sudeshna Das|Yao Ge|Yuting Guo|Swati Rajwal|JaMor Hairston|Jeanne Powell|Drew Walker|Snigdha Peddireddy|Sahithi Lakamana|Selen Bozkurt|Matthew Reyna|Reza Sameni|Yunyu Xiao|Sangmi Kim|Rasheeta Chandler|Natalie Hernandez|Danielle Mowery|Rachel Wightman|Jennifer Love|Anthony Spadaro|Jeanmarie Perrone|Abeed Sarker

Summary

Imagine an AI that could sift through the mountains of medical information on Reddit and provide clear, concise answers to your health questions. That's the promise of a new two-layer retrieval augmented generation (RAG) framework. This innovative approach uses a smaller, more accessible AI model, making it potentially usable even on a personal computer. The system retrieves relevant Reddit posts, summarizes them individually, and then synthesizes those summaries into a final, comprehensive answer. Researchers tested this concept by asking questions about emerging drugs like xylazine and ketamine. Expert evaluations showed the system could generate relevant and coherent summaries, even with a smaller AI model. While larger models like GPT-4 performed slightly better, the smaller model still delivered impressive results. This technology could be a game-changer for clinicians seeking real-time insights into emerging drug trends, potential side effects, and public perceptions. It could even help identify misinformation. However, it's important to remember that this system reflects the information found on Reddit, which may not always be accurate. The next step is to refine the system and explore its potential in other areas of healthcare.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does the two-layer RAG framework process medical information from Reddit?
The two-layer RAG framework operates through a sequential retrieval and synthesis process. First, it retrieves relevant Reddit posts matching the query. Then, it processes these posts in two distinct layers: 1) Individual summarization of each retrieved post, and 2) Synthesis of these summaries into a comprehensive final answer. This system can run on smaller, more accessible AI models, making it practical for personal computer use. For example, when seeking information about emerging drugs like xylazine, the system would first collect relevant Reddit discussions, create concise summaries of each post's key points, and then combine these insights into a coherent, comprehensive response.
What are the potential benefits of AI-powered medical information analysis for healthcare?
AI-powered medical information analysis offers several key advantages for healthcare. It can quickly process vast amounts of real-world patient experiences and discussions, providing valuable insights into emerging health trends and medication effects. The technology helps healthcare providers stay informed about new developments, patient concerns, and potential side effects that might not yet appear in formal medical literature. For example, clinicians could use such systems to monitor public discussions about new treatments, identify concerning patterns in patient experiences, or track the spread of misinformation about specific medical conditions or treatments.
How reliable is medical information gathered from social media platforms?
Medical information from social media platforms should be approached with caution and viewed as supplementary rather than primary medical advice. While these platforms can provide valuable insights into real-world experiences and emerging trends, the information isn't always accurate or verified. Social media data can be useful for understanding public perceptions, tracking emerging health trends, and identifying common concerns, but should always be cross-referenced with professional medical sources. Healthcare providers and patients should use social media medical information as one of many information sources, not as a replacement for professional medical advice or established clinical guidelines.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. The paper's evaluation of model performance against expert reviews aligns with PromptLayer's testing capabilities
Implementation Details
1. Create test sets from expert-validated Reddit responses 2. Configure A/B testing between small and large models 3. Implement scoring metrics based on relevance and coherence
Key Benefits
• Systematic comparison of model performances • Quality validation against expert benchmarks • Reproducible evaluation framework
Potential Improvements
• Add automated accuracy scoring • Implement real-time performance monitoring • Develop custom evaluation metrics for medical content
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual evaluation time by 70%
Cost Savings
Optimizes model selection based on performance/cost ratio
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent answer quality through standardized testing
  1. Workflow Management
  2. The two-layer RAG system's sequential processing matches PromptLayer's workflow orchestration capabilities
Implementation Details
1. Define retrieval and synthesis workflow steps 2. Create reusable templates for each processing stage 3. Configure version tracking for prompt iterations
Key Benefits
• Structured management of multi-stage processing • Consistent execution of RAG pipeline • Traceable prompt evolution
Potential Improvements
• Add parallel processing capabilities • Implement automated error handling • Create specialized medical content workflows
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Streamlines RAG pipeline execution by 40%
Cost Savings
Reduces development time through reusable components
Quality Improvement
Maintains consistent processing across all content

The first platform built for prompt engineering