Published
Jul 18, 2024
Updated
Jul 18, 2024

Decoding User Satisfaction: What Follow-Up Questions Reveal About Search

Using LLMs to Investigate Correlations of Conversational Follow-up Queries with User Satisfaction
By
Hyunwoo Kim|Yoonseo Choi|Taehyun Yang|Honggu Lee|Chaneon Park|Yongju Lee|Jin Young Kim|Juho Kim

Summary

Ever wonder what happens *after* you ask a search engine a question? Researchers dove into the world of conversational search, exploring how your follow-up questions reveal hidden clues about whether you're actually happy with the answers you get. Turns out, those follow-ups aren't just refinements—they're a rich tapestry of user intent. This research digs into actual search logs from Naver Cue:, a commercial conversational search engine. Through in-depth analysis, they uncovered fascinating patterns. For example, if you find yourself repeatedly clarifying your initial question or excluding specific terms, it could signal a less-than-stellar search experience. Why? Often, these follow-up types show users struggling to articulate their needs or receiving unhelpful initial results. On the other hand, seeking additional information related to a satisfactory answer paints a different picture – one of a user diving deeper into a topic. This research not only classifies follow-up queries but also demonstrates how these insights can be applied using large language models (LLMs). By training LLMs on their newly developed taxonomy, the researchers can automatically classify large datasets of conversational search logs. This is huge for search engines. By understanding the underlying motivations behind those follow-up questions, they can build more intuitive, responsive systems. Think proactive suggestions, clarifying questions from the engine itself, and even personalized search paths tailored to your unique follow-up style. While there are challenges in automating search quality evaluation (hello, potential LLM biases!), this research opens a fascinating window into the future of search. It's a step towards creating search engines that truly understand and respond to what you're *really* looking for.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How do Large Language Models (LLMs) classify follow-up search queries according to the research?
LLMs are trained on a specialized taxonomy developed by the researchers to automatically classify follow-up queries in conversational search logs. The process involves: 1) Training the LLM on the developed taxonomy of follow-up query types, 2) Processing large datasets of conversation logs to identify patterns, and 3) Categorizing queries based on user intent signals like clarifications, exclusions, or topic expansions. For example, if a user asks 'What are the best restaurants in NYC?' followed by 'excluding Italian food,' the LLM would classify this as a refinement-based exclusion query, indicating potential dissatisfaction with initial results.
Why are follow-up questions important for improving search engine performance?
Follow-up questions serve as valuable indicators of user satisfaction and search quality. They help search engines understand whether users found what they were looking for in their initial search. When users ask follow-up questions that dive deeper into a topic, it usually signals satisfaction with the initial results. Conversely, clarification questions or exclusions often indicate dissatisfaction. This knowledge enables search engines to create more intuitive experiences, offer better suggestions, and develop personalized search paths. For businesses, this means better user engagement and reduced user frustration.
How can understanding search patterns improve user experience in digital products?
Understanding search patterns helps create more intuitive and responsive digital experiences. By analyzing how users refine their searches, products can better anticipate user needs and provide more relevant results upfront. This leads to reduced search time, more accurate results, and higher user satisfaction. For example, an e-commerce platform could use search pattern analysis to improve product recommendations, implement smart filters, or suggest related categories based on common follow-up patterns. This creates a more streamlined shopping experience and potentially increases conversion rates.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. Enables systematic testing of LLM-based query classification models across different taxonomies and datasets
Implementation Details
Set up batch testing pipelines for query classification models, implement A/B testing for different taxonomy versions, create evaluation metrics based on user satisfaction signals
Key Benefits
• Automated validation of classification accuracy • Systematic comparison of different taxonomies • Quick identification of classification errors
Potential Improvements
• Integration with real-time user feedback • Enhanced bias detection mechanisms • Cross-model performance comparison tools
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual classification effort by 80%
Cost Savings
Minimizes resources needed for query analysis through automation
Quality Improvement
More consistent and reliable query classification results
  1. Analytics Integration
  2. Monitors and analyzes patterns in follow-up query classifications to improve search quality
Implementation Details
Deploy analytics pipeline to track classification performance, implement monitoring dashboards, set up alert systems for quality metrics
Key Benefits
• Real-time visibility into classification performance • Data-driven optimization of search responses • Early detection of classification anomalies
Potential Improvements
• Advanced pattern recognition capabilities • Customizable reporting interfaces • Predictive analytics for user satisfaction
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces time to identify and resolve classification issues by 60%
Cost Savings
Optimizes resource allocation through data-driven insights
Quality Improvement
Enhanced accuracy in predicting user satisfaction

The first platform built for prompt engineering